The moment one feels their learning is complete, they cease to grow. Uncovering secrets of the universe has been a passionate undertaking of man since the beginning of time. The medium of discovery and its dissemination changed, but the quest was always the same: know more and grow more. eLearning is the latest medium to create, distribute and acquire knowledge.
It is an essential mundane activity that is as natural as nourishment and sleep. It has captured entire sectors of economies, rendering efficient functionality in people, places and processes. However, a certain degree of reluctance has been observed in the implementation of e-learning pedagogy and andragogy in the education sector. The corporate sector is relatively less resistant to the latest methods, owing to the mandate of technology skill upgrade in employees. Furthermore, the availability of trained trainers eases individuals into smooth learning curves. The education sector continues to experience the culture change phenomenon, in which the old players seem to argue against e-learning. They blame it for being cumbersome and fussy. In this article, the situations of resistance and barriers to adopt e-learning are presented with complete solutions on overcoming them. In short, a viable potion for progressive universities!
Problem 1: Comprehensive Evaluation of Learning Objectives
Learning objectives assigned for a course to be completed in the entire year or semester is difficult to assess. The final exam has enough time constraints to enable it to focus on the latest material covered. A comprehensive exam places the burden on the learner to re-learn the entire syllabus covered within the appointed time. It also places pressure on the instructor to showcase the acquisition of learning objectives in their classrooms. As a result, the final exam is the most dreaded event of the year!
Solution: e-Portfolio to evidence performance
E-Portfolios are an excellent method to present learning in the form of artifacts and reflections for a particular time period. It shows sequential submissions with consecutive improvement in performance and learning. It is easy to implement and demonstrate. It is also a mode of communication between the learner, their parents and the instructor. Attractive tools and online solutions for developing e-portfolios are available that feature user-friendly environments. E-portfolios are similar to websites and instill the benefits of ownership and autonomy towards learning.
Problem 2: Lack of Motivation
It is a known fact that classroom disruption is the leading source of stress for teachers, even in a progressive university Traditional lessons are relatively “teacher-centered”, with reduced opportunities for learner involvement. One may have experienced an event in which disengaged learners would bring mobile devices for gaming and other non-classroom related activities during the lesson time. With technology popularity in the digital youth, such incidences are common. There is a danger of reduced achievement in performance testing leading to lost opportunities later in life.
Solution: e-Learning tools in the classroom
Using training tools that generate lessons in the form of attractive videos (linking classroom concepts to real-world applications) cartoons (instead of boring presentations) and games (instead of boring projects). Such tools are bound to engage the technology inclined learner, who seeks entertainment from such tools while getting educated. Empowering learners with such tools has another advantage: learner-generated content. This is a direct application of the adage: The best way to learn a concept is to teach it! Some classrooms show astonishing success rates when learners are taught a concept and asked to replicate a game environment to demonstrate their understanding. E-learning creates learning communities.
Problem 3: Varying Learning Styles and a Traditional Classroom Lesson
When Gardner postulated twelve Multiple Intelligences, he explained elaborately the situations that favor each intelligence type. Almost three decades later, teachers continue to demonstrate affinity towards “talking head” teaching style. As a result, the performance measured shows success in some learners and average performance from equally or sometimes superiorly competent learners. This makes learning non-conducive to an equal opportunity providing environment.
Solution: e-Learning caters to various learning styles
Multi-media is a self-explanatory term. It implies to the multi-sensory appeal of technology. Users can now enjoy information using their five senses (olfactory titillation is still under development but will be released inevitably!). Augmented Reality has given a new meaning to mobile learning. It mixes digital environment with real environment, heightening the learning pleasure of kinesthetic learners. Enhances in audio and visual quality has attracted even more consumers, who regularly produce learning material, regardless of their age. Teachers using e-learning tools in the classroom can be confident that they are creating “learner-centered” classrooms.
Problem 4: Isolation vs. Social Learning
The traditional classroom provides a competitive element that motivates achievers to establish new performance records. But this competition is limited to the classroom itself. Moreover sharing classroom performance regularly with parents through daily dairies is cumbersome and requires discipline. Problem arises with learners residing in distant location from parents where performance report sharing becomes critical for learner success. Another pronounced drawback of traditional learning is the feeling of isolation in terms of learning activities. Physical collaboration that is after classroom hours is becoming increasingly difficult owing to differing schedules of individuals.
Solution: Social Media for Learning
Utilizing social media tools to shift the negative activities to more constructive ones is a new wave catching up in classrooms whose teachers are tech savvy. A growing trend in schools is the use of Edmodo that allows parents to receive daily updates and upcoming events in a notification through email. Twittering is another medium in which learners actively debate on a topic given by the teacher. Grades are awarded based on quality of feedback on others’ comments and questions. In the past, discussion forum in a traditional LMS (Learning Management System) looked somber as compared to the affective features of social media. LMS solution providers like Talentlms have integrated several social media tools in the community knowledge sharing forums, making learning versatile. This induces learners to post more quality messages and learn more from each other. Thus Social Media has shifted the “knowledge development” focus of a traditional classroom to “knowledge management”. Try Etherpad, Voicethread and Netvibes for knowledge and social engagement.
Problem 5: Teaching Abstract Concepts
One of the biggest challenges of teaching is the ability to convey knowledge accurately for constructive use. This strategy makes teaching an art. Concepts like scaffolding and zone of proximal development (ZPD) are meaningless if teachers do not know how and when to introduce hard to teach concepts. In an effort to do the job better, many teachers try to use technology to aid their teaching. They involuntarily create digital learning environments that are exact replicas of physical classrooms. “Skeumorphism” is the term coined by Dongsong, Z., Zhao, J., Lina, Z., & Nunamaker, J. F. (2004) that explains this tendency. Thus the approach to teach a difficult concept remains unchanged.
Solution: Game Development to Learn Abstract Concepts
Game Development is not an art restricted to professionals of the gaming industry anymore. It is readily available as SAS (Software as a Service) applications with user friendly tools to create learning environments within games. Countless prototypes have been introduced in the education sector that uses narration, role play, problem solving and decision making features. In fact, tools available to create games are so easy to use that learners of all ages can participate as game creators to show their understanding of abstract concepts in the form of games.
The problems and solutions you pose are spot on for validating the Common Core State Standards recently adopted by 43 states for public education.
The standards call for performance-based assessments or product-based learning projects which call for students’ ability to demonstrate their learning. Problem #1 and the solution e-learning provides addressed the requirements of those standards beautifully. Not only do student put into action the recently-learned concepts (reading/writing portfolios are a classic informal assessment tool in elementary) but students are able to self-assess their own growth.
Problem #2 and Problem #5 are the same, in my opinion. Teacher-centered classroom are boring. Again, the CCSS call for the teacher becoming the facilitator/guide, rather than the spoon-feeder of information. Part of Problem #2 is really Problem #3 in that traditional classroom do not offer something for everyone. Students with ADD, ADHD, and OCD find them especially difficult. Sitting still and listening to someone talk endlessly can be torturous. Maturity is required to listen critically and attentively. Unfortunately, not all lectures/lessons are prepared carefully and with a definitive purpose. Building an e-learning experience demands a carefully constructed plan with a purpose. When done well, e-learning can provide differentiation, formative assessment to inform further instruction, immediate feedback, and interaction. Differentiation is not just about the level of instruction—it is also providing choices based on student interest and a say in the type of projects/learning activities they will pursue to achieve a particular learning goal. Formative assessments require logging missed questions and tracking data—time that teachers simply do not have time to do. An informal, computer-based activity with a feedback mechanism can log the data.
The strength of e-learning is that it requires a great deal of planning and analysis on behalf of the teacher before it is implemented. Perhaps this is why it hasn’t caught on? For example, I was shocked to discover that teachers in my district plan week-to-week. When I came in and prepared a Quarter Matrix complete with all the language arts elements, I was viewed as quite odd and overly ambitious. It made perfect sense to me–how does one get students to the end results without a road map? Shouldn’t our conversation about the quarter exam involve CONTENT not FORMAT (i.e. “I think it should be multiple choice with 50 questions, don’t you?”). The end result, or “big assessment shouldn’t be about memorizing facts, people, places, etc. It’s about students’ ability to IMPLEMENT and demonstrate mastery of skills and strategies.
Thanks for the detailed comment and point of view.
I agree that we should focus more on what brings results and not about the process itself. It is also extremely beneficial to offer the BIG PICTURE to users rather than giving them pieces of information here and there without a grand overview. Having the big picture gives you a sense of purpose and turns isolated tasks to meanigful activities.
In retrospective, I always learned better when I had that grand overview.
As a side note, there is a book, called “A short history of nearly everything” — http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Short_History_of_Nearly_Everything
It tells the story of science through the lives of people that produced remarkable results. Understanding how we figured out that the earth is round, makes a lot more sense than then information itself. I highly recommend it for anyone teaching anything.
We love Bill Bryson, thank you for the recommendation! Reading his purpose for writing this book made me very sad. Science has been an afterthought in our children’s education through grade 8. When I taught high school, I would often hear science teachers complain aloud —how could they get to high school without knowing the basics?
Thinking critically is the scientific method in action. When e-learning is learner-based (resources provided but learning activities not dictated), it opens up and encourages exploration of concepts and pursuing answers to questions. It is one step away from “one size fits all”—the very thing that discourages exploration.